Steve Schmitt’s Sports Treasures Plus (4.8 ⭐)
Independent collector notes and community insights below.
🏆 About
Owner Steve Schmitt has curated one of the most impressive and uncommon sports memorabilia collections in the world. Now, he has taken his stockpile and turned it into Sports Treasures Plus, a one-of-a-kind retail experience located in Stoughton
💬 Collector Notes
Independent editorial assessment
Schmitt’s is old school in the best way—tons of vintage singles and binders to dig through if you’re hunting for ’70s and ’80s cards. Not much TCG here; it’s mainly baseball with some football and basketball mixed in. The staff knows their eras, and the pricing isn’t eBay-comped but more grounded in show-floor logic.
Who this shop is (and isn’t) for
✅ Best For
- Sports card collectors
- Vintage collectors
- High-end / investment collectors
- Sealed wax buyers
- Hobby box and graded card buyers
⛔ Not Ideal For
- Pokémon/TCG collectors
- Kids & beginner collectors
- Looking for deep singles inventory
- Seeking in-store play environments
⭐ Review Summary
Customers consistently highlight the wide selection of sports cards, especially vintage singles and memorabilia, as a major strength of Steve Schmitt’s Sports Treasures Plus. Reviewers also mention the store being well-organized and commend the knowledgeable staff for their helpfulness and passion for the hobby.
Google Reviews Rating: 4.8
Total Reviews: (21)
📍 Location & Contact
- Address: 1016 Nygaard St
- City: Stoughton
- Phone : (608) 354-3389
⏰ Store Hours
- Sunday: 11 AM-5 PM
- Monday: Closed
- Tuesday: 11 AM-5 PM
- Wednesday: 11 AM-5 PM
- Thursday: 11 AM-5 PM
- Friday: 11 AM-5 PM
- Saturday: 11 AM-5 PM
Share Your Collector Experience & Feedback