The Bullpen Sports Collectibles (4 ⭐)
Independent collector notes and community insights below.
🏆 About
We’re a sports memorabilia store offering fine and rare examples of important baseball memorabilia. We have a special appreciation and focus on the history of the game, which includes vintage and signed items from the 19th century to modern day baseball. We also offer appraisal and authentication services. Members of the Professional Autograph Dealers Association.
💬 Collector Notes
Independent editorial assessment
Definitely an old school vibe—boxes piled up, cards everywhere, but loads to dig through if you’ve got the patience. Good mix of wax and singles, with a wall of slabs that’s decent but mostly modern stuff. The owner knows his comps and isn’t afraid to talk shop, which is rare these days—fair deals if you know your values.
Who this shop is (and isn’t) for
✅ Best For
- Sports card collectors
- Vintage collectors
- High-end / investment collectors
- Slabbed card buyers
- Sealed wax buyers
⛔ Not Ideal For
- Pokémon/TCG collectors
- Kids & beginner collectors
- Looking for deep singles inventory
- Seeking in-store play environments
⭐ Review Summary
Reviews consistently mention that The Bullpen Sports Collectibles offers a broad selection of sports card boxes, singles, and memorabilia, with a particular emphasis on baseball and basketball. Customers frequently highlight the knowledgeable and approachable owner, though some note the shop has a cluttered or crowded layout.
Google Reviews Rating: 4
Total Reviews: (4)
📍 Location & Contact
- Address: at B & B Rare Books Suite 500 (BY APPOINTMENT ONLY
- City: 165 Madison Ave, New York
- Phone : (646) 948-9600
⏰ Store Hours
- Sunday: Closed
- Monday: 12-6 PM
- Tuesday: 12-6 PM
- Wednesday: 12-6 PM
- Thursday: 12-6 PM
- Friday: 12-6 PM
- Saturday: Closed
Share Your Collector Experience & Feedback