Overtime Sports (4.6 ⭐)

Independent collector notes and community insights below.

Overtime Sports

πŸ† About

Buy, sell, trade of sports and non sports collectables and memorablilia. Specializing is shirts, jerseys, jackets, buttons, pins, hats, bobbleheads, cards and autographs. Pokemon,comic books.

πŸ’¬ Collector Notes

Independent editorial assessment

Solid mix of wax and singles, with a decent wall of high-end but also some mid-range stuff worth comping. Staff actually knows their stuffβ€”no fluff, just straight talkβ€”so you can ask about comps or grading without getting blank stares. Not a ton of TCG, so it’s more for the sports head than the PokΓ©mon crowd.

Who this shop is (and isn’t) for

βœ… Best For

  • Sports card collectors
  • Sealed wax buyers
  • Hobby box and graded card buyers
  • Collectors interested in supplies and memorabilia
  • High-end / investment collectors

β›” Not Ideal For

  • PokΓ©mon/TCG collectors
  • Looking for deep singles inventory
  • Seeking investment-grade cards
  • Seeking in-store play environments

⭐ Review Summary

Overtime Sports is praised for its large selection of sports cards, memorabilia, and collectibles, with many customers noting the store is well-organized and clean. Reviewers frequently mention the staff as knowledgeable, helpful, and willing to assist both new and experienced collectors.

Google Reviews Rating: 4.6
Total Reviews: (114)

πŸ“ Location & Contact

  • Address: 6248 E Speedway Blvd
  • Phone : (520) 367-5798

⏰ Store Hours

  • Sunday: 10:30 AM-6 PM
  • Monday: 10:30 AM-6 PM
  • Tuesday: 10:30 AM-6 PM
  • Wednesday: 10:30 AM-6 PM
  • Thursday: 10:30 AM-6 PM
  • Friday: 10:30 AM-6 PM
  • Saturday: 10:30 AM-6 PM

πŸ“£ Media Mentions

πŸ—£ Shop Owner Insights

Share Your Collector Experience & Feedback

Tell other collectors about your experience with this shop. What cards did you find? How was the service?