America’s Pastime (3.8 ⭐)
Independent collector notes and community insights below.
🏆 About
Our retail store sells all sports cards. Baseball, football, basketball, hockey. We sell vintage and current single cards. Rookie cards, stars and comments for set builders. We sell packs and sealed boxes, complete sets. We sell all hobby supplies. We have been in business since 1989 and we offer service and answer questions with a smile.
💬 Collector Notes
Independent editorial assessment
Solid spot if you’re chasing modern singles or looking to comp slabs—plenty of baseball heat with some decent football sprinkled in. The place runs clean and tight, and the staff actually know the hobby, which helps if you’re trying to trade up or unload bulk. Not much in the way of junk wax or vintage, so don’t come expecting 80s sets or smoking deals in the dollar box.
Who this shop is (and isn’t) for
✅ Best For
- Vintage collectors
- High-end / investment collectors
- Slabbed card buyers
- Sealed wax buyers
- Hobby box and graded card buyers
⛔ Not Ideal For
- Kids & beginner collectors
- Looking for deep singles inventory
- Seeking in-store play environments
⭐ Review Summary
This shop is frequently praised for its wide selection of sports cards and memorabilia, with customers noting especially good stock in baseball and modern cards. Staff are described as knowledgeable and helpful, and the store is mentioned as being clean and well-organized.
Google Reviews Rating: 3.8
Total Reviews: (66)
📍 Location & Contact
- Address: 25-05A Broadway
- City: Fair Lawn
- Phone : (201) 294-7852
⏰ Store Hours
- Sunday: Closed
- Monday: 11:30 AM-6 PM
- Tuesday: 11:30 AM-6 PM
- Wednesday: 11:30 AM-6 PM
- Thursday: 11:30 AM-6 PM
- Friday: 11:30 AM-6 PM
- Saturday: 11:30 AM-6 PM
Share Your Collector Experience & Feedback