Superstars and Superheroes (4.5 ⭐)

Independent collector notes and community insights below.

Superstars and Superheroes

πŸ† About

Locally Owned And Operated For Over 30 Years, With a vast inventory of vintage collectibles, trading cards, and comic books.

πŸ’¬ Collector Notes

Independent editorial assessment

For the best experience at this shop, you must be prepared to “dig.” Strategic Tip for 2026: If you are looking for a specific issue or player, call or message Larry ahead of time. Multiple regulars note that he will pre-sort boxes and have them ready on the counter for you to browse upon arrival. Pro Tip: This is one of the few shops in Iowa that still offers a “Buy 3, Get 1 Free” deal on new comics, making it a budget-friendly staple for weekly readers. Space Warning: The store is notoriously tight; reviewers mention that more than 3-4 people can make the aisles impassable. Pricing Strategy: Larry typically adheres strictly to price guide values (Beckett/Overstreet). While this means you won’t find many “accidental” steals, his transparency and honesty about card conditions are highly respected by the local community. Selling Tip: Larry is an active buyer of Silver and Bronze Age comics, but be prepared for an honest assessmentβ€”he values his reputation for fairness and won’t sugarcoat the grade of a collection.

Who this shop is (and isn’t) for

βœ… Best For

  • Vintage collectors
  • Sealed wax buyers
  • Hobby box and graded card buyers
  • Kids & beginner collectors

β›” Not Ideal For

  • Kids & beginner collectors
  • Looking for deep singles inventory
  • Seeking in-store play environments
  • High-end buyers only

⭐ Review Summary

Superstars and Superheroes is a legendary “time capsule” shop in Davenport that has served the Quad Cities for over 42 years. Owned and operated by Larry, who is famously known for remembering customers’ names even after decades away, the store is a high-density archive of vintage comic books and sports cards (1950s–modern). This is a true “collector’s cave”β€”the shop is narrow, packed with longboxes, and possesses that nostalgic “old paper” scent that enthusiasts adore. While it lacks the modern, spacious feel of newer retail chains, Larry’s encyclopedic knowledge of his inventory is unparalleled; he can often point a collector to a specific box for a niche silver-age book or vintage rookie card instantly. It is a premier destination for those who enjoy the “thrill of the hunt,” though the cramped quarters mean it is best visited in small groups.

Google Reviews Rating: 4.5
Total Reviews: (78)

πŸ“ Location & Contact

  • Address: 1527 N Harrison St
  • Phone : (563) 323-4392

⏰ Store Hours

  • Sunday: Closed
  • Monday: Closed
  • Tuesday: 11 AM-5 PM
  • Wednesday: 11 AM-5 PM
  • Thursday: 11 AM-5 PM
  • Friday: 11 AM-5 PM
  • Saturday: 11 AM-5 PM

πŸ“£ Media Mentions

πŸ—£ Shop Owner Insights

Share Your Collector Experience & Feedback

Tell other collectors about your experience with this shop. What cards did you find? How was the service?