Black Cat Collectibles LLC (5 ⭐)

💬 Collector Notes

Independent editorial assessment

This store is a “hidden gem” specifically for collectors of non-sports memorabilia. While they do have trading cards and nerdy merchandise, the standout feature is the sheer volume of unique, floor-to-ceiling inventory that is refreshed weekly. It is a favorite for “toy hunters” coming from out of state (and even out of the country). A common piece of advice from regulars is to call ahead, as they have been known to close earlier than posted hours occasionally, and to do several laps of the store because there is simply too much to see in one pass.