Nicodemus Cards & Gaming (4.5 ⭐)
Independent collector notes and community insights below.
🏆 About
Nicodemus Cards & Gaming is a premier trading card store located in Warsaw, IN, serving surrounding areas since 2020. Specializing in trading cards, gaming supplies, and card grading, we are your one-stop shop for all things related to card collecting and gaming. Our store offers a vibrant atmosphere for card enthusiasts to participate in tournaments, engage in open play sessions, and connect with fellow collectors. Whether you’re a seasoned pro or just getting started, Nicodemus Cards & Gaming is the ultimate destination for all your trading card needs.
💬 Collector Notes
Independent editorial assessment
Heavy on the TCG side—tons of MTG singles and sealed, and the Pokémon section runs deep for both new and vintage. It’s a little cramped, definitely old school with product boxes and binders stacked all over, but they know their stuff when you’re asking about deck builds or rare pulls. Not a spot for slabs or high-end sports wax—more commander league than comping chrome.
Who this shop is (and isn’t) for
✅ Best For
- Pokémon collectors
- TCG players
- Vintage collectors
- High-end / investment collectors
- Slabbed card buyers
⛔ Not Ideal For
- Sports-only collectors
- Kids & beginner collectors
- Prefer quiet browsing
- Looking for deep singles inventory
- Seeking investment-grade cards
⭐ Review Summary
Nicodemus Cards & Gaming is frequently praised for its extensive selection of trading card games, especially Magic: The Gathering and Pokémon, as well as a sizable inventory of tabletop gaming products. Reviewers mention the staff are knowledgeable and helpful, though a few note that the store is a bit cluttered.
Google Reviews Rating: 4.5
Total Reviews: (60)
📍 Location & Contact
- Address: 118 W Market St
- City: Warsaw
- Phone : (574) 549-9945
⏰ Store Hours
- Sunday: 10 AM-6 PM
- Monday: 10 AM-6 PM
- Tuesday: Closed
- Wednesday: 10 AM-6 PM
- Thursday: 10 AM-6 PM
- Friday: 10 AM-6 PM
- Saturday: 10 AM-6 PM
Share Your Collector Experience & Feedback