Lefty’s Sports Card Store (3.8 ⭐)
Independent collector notes and community insights below.
🏆 About
Serving the Bay Area sports cards and memorabilia since 1988.
💬 Collector Notes
Independent editorial assessment
Walking into Lefty’s feels like stepping into an old-school memorabilia shop, with walls of autographs, boxes of cards, and the kind of cluttered density that suggests decades of buying and selling. There’s a strong San Francisco sports presence and plenty of sealed product and singles to browse, but the atmosphere can feel uneven depending on who’s behind the counter and what you’re trying to buy or sell. Some visits come across as friendly and conversational, while others feel transactional and tense, especially when prices or valuations come up. It’s a place that carries a lot of history and inventory, but also one where expectations should be set carefully before making any major purchase or consignment decision.
Who this shop is (and isn’t) for
✅ Best For
- Sports card collectors
- Sealed wax buyers
- Hobby box and graded card buyers
- Event nights & tournaments
- Organized play & events
⛔ Not Ideal For
- Pokémon/TCG collectors
- Prefer quiet browsing
- Looking for deep singles inventory
- Seeking in-store play environments
⭐ Review Summary
Lefty’s Sports Card Store has a long history in the Bay Area and is known for a deep inventory of sports cards, Pokémon, and autographed memorabilia, along with frequent athlete signing events. Some customers praise the nostalgic feel, wide selection, and the chance to find team-specific collectibles, especially for local franchises. However, recent reviews are sharply divided, with repeated complaints about sealed product being priced well above MSRP or even current market, and concerns raised about customer service and consignment practices. While a portion of shoppers report fair deals and positive interactions, others describe experiences that felt unprofessional or overly profit-driven. The overall reputation today is mixed, ranging from a classic hobby stop to a store that has lost trust with part of its collector base.
Google Reviews Rating: 3.8
Total Reviews: (96)
📍 Location & Contact
- Address: 1859 El Camino Real
- City: Burlingame
- Phone : (650) 697-2274
⏰ Store Hours
- Sunday: 10 AM-6 PM
- Monday: 10 AM-6 PM
- Tuesday: 10 AM-6 PM
- Wednesday: 10 AM-6 PM
- Thursday: 10 AM-6 PM
- Friday: 10 AM-6 PM
- Saturday: 10 AM-6 PM
Share Your Collector Experience & Feedback